Page 18 of 19
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-08T07:30:29-07:00
by NicolasRobidoux
henrywho wrote:...
=> EWA/QuadraticJinc/USM does a wonderful job, giving nice perceived sharpness without (or with minimal) moire patterns.
=> EWA/Lagrange and EWA/Lanczos4/blur=0.8 closely follow, with slight moire patterns.
...
This, in particular, is interesting.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-08T08:04:20-07:00
by NicolasRobidoux
henrywho wrote:BTW, I think USM should be done under Linear RGB otherwise it will greatly affect the overall brightness of some feature patterns
From a "theoretical viewpoint", I agree.
The rule of thumb is: If you convolve, do it in linear light. USM is a convolution.
I'm not sure the rule of thumb is universal. But it is a good starting point.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-08T08:49:43-07:00
by henrywho
NicolasRobidoux wrote:henrywho wrote:BTW, I think USM should be done under Linear RGB otherwise it will greatly affect the overall brightness of some feature patterns
From a "theoretical viewpoint", I agree.
I've compared
[1] rgb -> resize -> usm -> srgb
[2] rgb -> resize -> srgb -> usm
[3] resize -> usm
[1] looks most "correct" for backpack.... having the most similar brightness as the original.
Perhaps XYZ would look good too?
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-08T10:17:00-07:00
by henrywho
This test case demonstrates another "feature" of USM: It enhances the "3D" look of the grass. EWA/Catrom and EWA/Lagrange can also simulate this effect. EWA/LanczosN/blur=0.8 cannot.
I should say .... a higher contrast on the grass area.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-08T17:08:46-07:00
by henrywho
As USM is also pushing values to the extreme, will it benefit from HDRI too?
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-10T17:47:04-07:00
by anthony
Possibly HDRI would improve USM. I think it may be a two pass convolve. Not certain.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-25T10:26:39-07:00
by NicolasRobidoux
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-25T11:52:09-07:00
by fmw42
Any idea or references to how anti-ringing works? I presume it is post-processing?
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2012-10-25T12:54:34-07:00
by NicolasRobidoux
madVR's AR (AntiRing) is proprietary and a loose "trade secret" of Mathias Rauen, the developer. It is an evolved version of what's discussed here:
http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=145358. Mathias Rauen = madshi.
There is something apparently related that was built into the Intel SandyBridge chip by Eric Gur, the main developer of the Intel QuickSync Decoder:
http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=162442. Another trade secret. Not so loose. Eric Gur = egur.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T05:47:32-07:00
by RitterRunkel
Hello and thx for all the knowledge so far! I've got three questions:
1. Any news on best downsampling methods for photographs, and what exactly (which algorithm) is lohalo and nohalo, coming up in gimp? There seems to be no lohalo/nohalo-equivalent in ImageMagick, or is there?
2. I'm quite happy with Catrom for very sharp downsampling of photographs not prone to moiré, EWA Lanczos3Sharpest for usual downsampling and EWA quadratic B-spline-windowed Jinc 3 in hard cases being prone to moiré. But I did some tests and I wonder about this (though less photographic) test case with downsampling to 50 or 33%:
Test image. What would be an ideal algorithm to retain the natural impression (mainly grey gradients)? My results look like this:
33% downsampled.
3. Almost all methods deliver RGB-color and the complementary colors as well (as seen in the downsampled pic). Seems, light grey + R -> R, but dark grey + R -> Cyan. This is the opposite of my personal impression! Would be happy to know why this is and how to avoid it ...
Thank you and kind regards,
Robin
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T06:39:47-07:00
by snibgo
Some non-photographic images are better downsampled in RGB space, rather than the default sRGB space:
Code: Select all
convert -colorspace RGB "2.20+Gamma+Calibration.png" -resize 33% -colorspace sRGB r.png
I don't know which filter might be better.
For algorithms "coming up in Gimp", you might ask in a Gimp forum.
EDIT: Sorry, I mis-typed that command. It should be:
Code: Select all
convert "2.20+Gamma+Calibration.png" -colorspace RGB -resize 33% -colorspace sRGB r.png
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T07:32:02-07:00
by RitterRunkel
snibgo wrote:Some non-photographic images are better downsampled in RGB space, rather than the default sRGB space
Already did that ... but tried your code, too, and all was fine, so I quickly figured out, what was wrong in my code. In my testing sigmoidal contrasting was left:
Code: Select all
convert x.png -colorspace RGB +sigmoidal-contrast 4,50% -filter Catrom -distort resize 33% -sigmoidal-contrast 4,50% -colorspace sRGB y.png
Sorry, would have been smarter to post my code here next to my question. So it's fine, I just have to figure out, when this sigmoidal-contrast makes sense. I read about using it to retain color otherwise lost during resizing. And it did ... somehow. ^^ But with 50% strange colors ...
snibgo wrote:For algorithms "coming up in Gimp", you might ask in a Gimp forum.
Oh, you're right for sure, but I thought some of the well known guys here are engaged in both developments ...
Thx for the reply!
So I'm able to retain color, depending on the strength of contrasting. But it would be very nice, if someone could describe how I can avoid this color switch at 50% of the gradient ... is there a way to get slight color without switching and maybe homogenous from top to bottom (other possibility than sigmoidal?)?
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T08:19:03-07:00
by holden
OT, but I just checked on this the other day:
http://libregraphicsworld.org/blog/entr ... rowdfunded
http://freedomsponsors.org/core/issue/7 ... arp-images
I've heard that downsizing in no more than 50% increments at a time helps, even sharpening at each level, but that would be up for experimentation IMO.
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T08:50:48-07:00
by RitterRunkel
holden wrote:I've heard that downsizing in no more than 50% increments at a time helps, even sharpening at each level, but that would be up for experimentation IMO.
Tried it, but didn't help. Think that stepwise resizing is meant to be helpful in sharpness and detail. But my problem is more color than luminance/moiré ... I'm able to produce homogenous gradients now, but colorless and grey. I'd like to retain slight color, at the moment by using sigmoidal contrast, but color switches from magenta to green, for example. Always in the middle: less magenta -> green, more magenta -> magenta. And this is the same for 60%:
60% resampled.
Interesting crowdfunding, thx for the hint! Would love to see more methods, either in gimp or in ImageMagick!
Re: best downsampling method for DSLR photographs
Posted: 2013-09-17T09:06:00-07:00
by snibgo
From this thread and
viewtopic.php?f=22&t=21415, it seems sigmoidal processing is suggested to reduce halos when enlarging, and not for reducing.
